Email list hosting service & mailing list manager

Re: [BCAB] Audio-description on DVD movies Paul Benson (16 Dec 2012 15:03 GMT)
Re: [BCAB] Audio-description on DVD movies Chris H (16 Dec 2012 17:10 GMT)
Re: [BCAB] Audio-description on DVD movies Clive Lever (16 Dec 2012 23:57 GMT)

Re: [BCAB] Audio-description on DVD movies Chris H 16 Dec 2012 17:10 GMT

You couldn't have said this better Paul. Until then if I get a Dvd and
it is audio described great but if not so be it.

Christopher Hallsworth

On 16/12/2012 15:03, Paul Benson wrote:
> Hello Chris and all,
>
> Surely the obvious solution, is to have Audio Description enabled as an industry standard on all DVD players as they leave the factory. Are DVD player manufacturers afraid that the sighted public are so stupid that they can not follow the instructions to disable the AD should they not wish to listen to it? The DVD player could have an option to easily and quickly silence the AD, or even switch it off permanently until re-activated by entering the menu. The former could be achieved by holding down a function key on the remote control, and then holding down the increase/decrease volume key, to raise/lower the volume of the AD soundtrack respectively.
>
> It's the usual problem, until legislation is passed forcing manufactures to act, then why should they voluntarily increase costs for a minority market?
>
> Paul Benson.
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Chris H - Email Address: christopherh40@gmail.com
> Sent On: 16/12/2012 14:12
> Sent To: BCAB Discussion List - Email Address: bcab@lists.bcab.org.uk
> Subject: Re: [BCAB] Audio-description on DVD movies
>
> You know guys this is one reason I have few if any Dvds. Frankly I can't
> be bothered to find out if a Dvd has audio description and then to find
> out how to enable it. If I receive a Dvd as a gift or as an item for
> myself, I just put up with it even if audio description is missing.
> Otherwise it's audio description on the tv all the way for me.
> Christopher Hallsworth
>
> On 16/12/2012 13:54, Clive Lever wrote:
>    i Susan and all,
>
>    here are my points:
>
>    1. RNIB butted out of the Audio-description movie issue when they
>    disbanded the broadcast support team.
>    2. Many of the audio-description tracks available on RNIB videos were
>    not ported through to the mainstream DVD when the new format replaced
>    the old.
>    3. You often have to read the very small print on a cover of a
>    commercially-available DVD of a film to find out whether it has
>    audio-description. This is not an ideal situation, because it
>    unwittingly works to the Les Barker-style principle: "If you can read
>    it, you don't need it."
>    4. It is still often the case that a title, either film or TV series,
>    for which AD has been done for the broadcast, has no A D available when
>    you buy the commercially-available item. There are relativly few DVD's
>    with audio suitable for children available to buy, which could exclude
>    blind  kids from the shared experience of watching a home video together.
>    5. Some blind people have tried to get a compromise by putting up sites
>    for sharing audio soundtracks of films/tv series plus a D, and run into
>    difficulties with copyright. Whatever happened to the Blidn Mice Movie
>    Vault, and who in their right minds could possibly consider it to be a
>    real threat to the level of sales of the actual movie with pictures to
>    have sound-only for people who cannot follow the bought item?
>    6. As has been pointed out already, you need sighted help every time you
>    want to hear an audio-described track on a purchased DVD, which must be
>    soul-destroying for any blind person into TV and movies who lives in a
>    household where there is no-one with reading vision.
>
>    Perhaps we need to raise awareness of the industry that we hare having
>    to put up with a level of service that the Deaf community would never
>    have tolerated, so, loads of subtitles, considerably less audio
>    description.
>
>    I am tempted to write to any actor and any agency still in my address
>    when I was compiling Guide Cats, asking them if they would press
>    film-makers and TV to do all they can to ensure DVDs of their work
>    are issued with Audio description.  I don't know how we would crack the
>    problem of DVD players with spoken menues unless we could get a company
>    interested in making them. Would COBOLT be too 'special' and clunky and
>    expensive? The ideal is to have speech menus incorporated into
>    mainstream sets.
>
>    Best,
>    Clive
>
>    ----- Original Message ----- From: "Sue & Ian"
>    <usinthedoghouse@blueyonder.co.uk
>
>
>
>    To: "BCAB Discussion List" <bcab@lists.bcab.org.uk
>    Sent: Sunday, December 16, 2012 12:08 PM
>    Subject: Re: [BCAB] Audio-description on DVD movies
>
>
>     Hi, Clive, I would be interestedin the answer to your question as
>     well. I am totally frustrated with Audio Description on dVd's. Regards
>     Susan Jones
>     ----- Original Message ----- From: "Clive Lever"
>     <clive.lever@btinternet.com
>     To: "BCAB Discussion List" <bcab@lists.bcab.org.uk ;
>     <access-uk@freelists.org
>     Sent: Sunday, December 16, 2012 10:22 AM
>     Subject: [BCAB] Audio-description on DVD movies
>
>
>      Hello all,
>
>      I want to open discussion about issues arising from the way
>      audio-description is or isn't available on commercially-produced DVD
>      movies. Please can someone tell me which is the best list for the topic.
>
>      Thanks,
>      Clive
>
>
>
>      --
>      To find out more about BCAB and the benefits that membership can
>      bring, please visit our website:
>      http://www.bcab.org.uk/
>
>      To manage your subscription to the BCAB mailing list, please visit
>      our website:
>      http://www.bcab.org.uk/bcab-discussion-list/
>
>      To discuss matters relating to the mailing list, please email
>      moderator@bcab.org.uk.
>
>
>     --
>     To find out more about BCAB and the benefits that membership can
>     bring, please visit our website:
>     http://www.bcab.org.uk/
>
>     To manage your subscription to the BCAB mailing list, please visit our
>     website:
>     http://www.bcab.org.uk/bcab-discussion-list/
>
>     To discuss matters relating to the mailing list, please email
>     moderator@bcab.org.uk.
>
>
>
>